326 artifacts compiled from The Curse of Oak Island (Seasons 1–13) — coins, carved stones, structures, and more.
Compiled and cross-referenced from the official artifact vault and per-episode analyses. See Survey for the PC gaming survey.
Artifact vault entries featured per season, S1–S13.
Objects by century of manufacture (midpoint of each dated range) — the colonial-era peak is the story of the island.
| # | Artifact | Category | Location | Era | Origin | Featured |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 14th-century barter token {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S10E20 |
| 2 | 1671 Order of the Garter Medallion | Artifacts | Off-Island | Colonial | imported | S06E20 |
| 3 | 1700s spike | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S06 |
| 4 | 1704 stone {esc(x)} | Carved Stones | Island General | Colonial | local | S01E03 |
| 5 | Spanish half-real silver, 1781 (island general) {esc(x)} | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E10 |
| 6 | Small coin, 17th century (island general) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S05E08 |
| 7 | 1850 Cofferdam remains | Structures | Smith's Cove | Searcher Era | local | — |
| 8 | 18th-century wharf nail | Artifacts | Other | Colonial | imported | S05E05 |
| 9 | Adze Head | Tools | Island General | Colonial | local | — |
| 10 | Adze-marked wood | Materials | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S09E11 |
| 11 | Ancient trade weight {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S10E01 |
| 12 | Annular ware pottery, early 1750s-1760s (swamp pathway, Lot 13) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S08E23 |
| 13 | Arcadia Stone {esc(x)} | Structures | Eye Of The Swamp | Medieval | local | S07E09 |
| 14 | Ardoise Hill Gravestone (C. Manulis, 1558) | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Colonial | local | — |
| 15 | Ashbury ware ceramic shard | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E19 |
| 16 | Axe-cut tree stumps | Materials | The Swamp | Medieval | local | S11E15 |
| 17 | Axe-cut wood slivers (Hole 201X) | Materials | Money Pit | Colonial | local | — |
| 18 | Axe Head | Tools | Island General | Colonial | imported | S08E01 |
| 19 | Axe | Tools | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | — |
| 20 | 'Ball' name tag | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | S04E08 |
| 21 | Barrel hoop (iron, large) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | imported | S10E20 |
| 22 | Barrel of a hand cannon | Artifacts | The Swamp | Medieval | imported | S13E04 |
| 23 | Barrote Nail (Spanish Galleon) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S04E15 |
| 24 | Bedford Petroglyph of an Eight-pointed Star | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Medieval | local | S02E03 |
| 25 | Black Glass Jewel | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | imported | S13E08 |
| 26 | Block and tackle hook | Tools | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S10E17 |
| 27 | Blue clay layer | Materials | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S06E09 |
| 28 | Boatswain's whistle (bone/ivory) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Medieval | local | S12E02 |
| 29 | Bone fragments and periwinkle shell (Borehole 10X sieving) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | local | — |
| 30 | Bone-handled knife | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | S07E16 |
| 31 | Possible booby trap spike {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | imported | S07E20 |
| 32 | Borehole 10-X camera images | Documents | Money Pit | Modern | imported | — |
| 33 | Box drains (fan-shaped) {esc(x)} | Structures | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | S01E02 |
| 34 | Decorative brass boat fitting | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S05E11 |
| 35 | Brass fragment (Borehole 21) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | local | — |
| 36 | Britannia copper, 1673 (Charles II, Lot 16) | Coins | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S05E03 |
| 37 | Britannia copper, 1694 (William III, Lot 16) | Coins | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S05E03 |
| 38 | Britannia coin, 17th century (Lot 32, S09E13) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S09E13 |
| 39 | British copper coin, 17th century (Lot 32, S09E11) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S09E11 |
| 40 | British naval officer's button {esc(x)} | Buttons | Island General | Searcher Era | imported | S08E23 |
| 41 | British Tudor portcullis coin, 1500s (Lot 5) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11E01 |
| 42 | Brooklyn Symbols | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Modern | local | S10E11 |
| 43 | Bush Scythe Fragments | Tools | Island General | Colonial | imported | — |
| 44 | Cap Badge Fragment (Money Pit Dunfield spoils) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S13E24 |
| 45 | Carved wood piece (possible tool handle) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S09E09 |
| 46 | Cast-iron cooking pot fragment | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S13E02 |
| 47 | Cast iron stove (starburst design) | Artifacts | Shoreline | Modern | imported | S12E06 |
| 48 | Cement/concrete vault layer | Structures | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S02E04 |
| 49 | Chain link (Lot 5) | Artifacts | Island General | Pre-Discovery | imported | S11 |
| 50 | Chain with oval hand-forged links | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S10E06 |
| 51 | Chappell Vault | Structures | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S04E05 |
| 52 | Charcoal from the Stone Road | Artifacts | Other | Colonial | local | S08E15 |
| 53 | Charcoal layer | Materials | Money Pit | Ancient | local | — |
| 54 | Chinese cash coin, 400 BC-900 AD (Lot 15) | Coins | Lot 15 | Ancient | imported | S08E01 |
| 55 | Clay pipe bowl fragment | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | S08E24 |
| 56 | Clay pipe stem (4/64ths bore, Lot 5 round feature) | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | local | S13E03 |
| 57 | Clay pipe stem (Lot 5 stone feature, Miriam find) | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | local | S10E11 |
| 58 | Clay pipe stem (north shore seafloor) | Artifacts | Off-Island | Colonial | local | S11E01 |
| 59 | Clay Pipe Stem with "O" Inscription | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | local | S12E18 |
| 60 | Coconut fibre (Money Pit) | Materials | Money Pit | Medieval | local | S01E02 |
| 61 | Coconut fibre (Smith's Cove) | Materials | Smith's Cove | Medieval | local | S01E02 |
| 62 | Silver-gilt button, 1600s-1700s (Lot 5) | Buttons | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E25 |
| 63 | Coin with possible cross design, medieval (Money Pit) {esc(x)} | Coins | Money Pit | Medieval | imported | S02E02 |
| 64 | Concrete/cement wall | Structures | Smith's Cove | Modern | local | S06E12 |
| 65 | Starburst Button (silver-plated) | Artifacts | Shoreline | Colonial | imported | S07E01 |
| 66 | Copper coin, pre-1816 (Lot 6, Samuel Ball property) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S04E06 |
| 67 | Copper coin, late 17th-early 18th century (swamp stone pathway, S8E10) | Coins | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E10 |
| 68 | Copper coin, late 17th-early 18th century (swamp stone pathway, S8E11) | Coins | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E11 |
| 69 | Copper Nameplate | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E11 |
| 70 | Copper shards (decorative box) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11E11 |
| 71 | Copper sheeting (decorative) | Artifacts | Island General | Pre-Discovery | imported | S11 |
| 72 | Copper ship nails (pair, 1720-1760) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E14 |
| 73 | Cornish miner's pick {esc(x)} | Tools | Money Pit | Searcher Era | imported | S05E07 |
| 74 | Creamware plate base, c. 1762-1763 (swamp pathway, Lot 13) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S08E24 |
| 75 | Crib spikes (multiple) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S06E16 |
| 76 | Crossbow bolt (Wroclawski/Dunfield) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S06E03 |
| 77 | Cut Spanish maravedi, 17th-18th century (Isaac's Point) {esc(x)} | Coins | Isaac's Point | Colonial | imported | S05E02 |
| 78 | Cut silver coin, 15th-18th century (Lot 5 round feature) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E01 |
| 79 | Cylindrical metal object (Borehole 10, Warnock Hersey) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | local | — |
| 80 | Dandy button | Buttons | Island General | Colonial | imported | S04E08 |
| 81 | Decorative iron hinges (pair, Spanish-style) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S05E13 |
| 82 | Decorative keyhole plate | Artifacts | Other | Colonial | local | S05E15 |
| 83 | Divider Compass | Tools | Other | Colonial | imported | S13E07 |
| 84 | Drill pipe section, 2-inch (MP-1 caisson) | Tools | Money Pit | Searcher Era | imported | S13E25 |
| 85 | Drilled Stone (Money Pit Area) | Artifacts | Money Pit | unknown | local | S03E11 |
| 86 | Drilled Stone (Lot 15) | Artifacts | Other | unknown | local | S08E02 |
| 87 | Drilled Stone (Lot 27) | Artifacts | Other | Modern | local | S13E07 |
| 88 | Drilled Stone (Nolan Property) | Artifacts | Other | Modern | local | S11E15 |
| 89 | Drilled Stone (Smith's Cove) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Pre-Discovery | local | S03E11 |
| 90 | Dutch Onion Bottle Glass | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E12 |
| 91 | Eelgrass layer | Materials | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S03E11 |
| 92 | English nail (1750s, Shaft 6) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S12E16 |
| 93 | Evans Stone - 13-branched tree carving in rock | Carved Stones | Shoreline | Colonial | local | S06E22 |
| 94 | Fireplace Hearth Foundation | Structures | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S08E20 |
| 95 | Flagstone layer | Structures | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S04E01 |
| 96 | Flat decking wood (carbon dated) | Materials | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S09E10 |
| 97 | Flat Stone with Hooked X | Carved Stones | The Swamp | Modern | local | S04E03 |
| 98 | Flower Button | Buttons | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E09 |
| 99 | Anchor Fluke | Artifacts | Money Pit | Medieval | local | — |
| 100 | Folded copper/brass piece (decorated) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S10E06 |
| 101 | Folded copper coin, post-medieval (Lot 5 round feature) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S13E08 |
| 102 | Folding skeleton key (cross-shaped) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Pre-Discovery | imported | S05E12 |
| 103 | Forest Axe Heads (3) | Tools | Island General | Colonial | imported | S08E04 |
| 104 | Garden Shaft | Structures | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S10E01 |
| 105 | George III "Cartwheel" twopence, 1797 (island general) | Coins | Island General | Pre-Discovery | imported | S06E01 |
| 106 | George III penny or halfpenny, 1760-1820 (Lot 5) | Coins | Island General | Pre-Discovery | imported | S11E13 |
| 107 | George Washington funeral urn medal, 1800 (swamp) | Coins | The Swamp | Pre-Discovery | imported | S13E16 |
| 108 | Glass fragments | Artifacts | Other | Colonial | imported | S06 |
| 109 | Glooscap Stone | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Medieval | local | S04E10 |
| 110 | Gold chain links (3) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Searcher Era | imported | S03E13 |
| 111 | Gold-colored knob | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E13 |
| 112 | Gold-Copper Alloy Fragments (Tumbaga) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S09E03 |
| 113 | Gold-gilded copper button | Buttons | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11 |
| 114 | Gold-plated brooch (leaded glass gem) | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S06E01 |
| 115 | Gold-plated coin, 18th century (Smith's Cove) | Coins | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S06E08 |
| 116 | Gold traces in water samples | Samples | Money Pit | Modern | local | S09 |
| 117 | Goose Paw (Palazzo Falson) | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Medieval | local | S12E23 |
| 118 | Goose Paw symbol (Brooklyn, NS) | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Pre-Discovery | local | S10E11 |
| 119 | Goose Paw symbol (Valkenburg, Netherlands) | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Medieval | local | S11E23 |
| 120 | Grapeshot (iron cannon ball) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S05E08 |
| 121 | H+O stone | Carved Stones | Island General | Pre-Discovery | local | S03E06 |
| 122 | Half Roman coin, c. 300 BC-600 AD (Lot 5) {esc(x)} | Coins | Island General | Ancient | imported | S10E20 |
| 123 | Hand chisel (iron, Northern Swamp) | Tools | The Swamp | Medieval | imported | S13E14 |
| 124 | Hand-forged chain links (Karma-1 shaft) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S13E17 |
| 125 | Hand-forged iron pintle | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S13E14 |
| 126 | Hand-forged nail (pre-1795) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E21 |
| 127 | Hand-forged rose head spike | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S05E01 |
| 128 | Hand-wrought iron spike (12th-13th century) | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S11 |
| 129 | Hand-wrought nail + nut/washer | Artifacts | South Shore | Colonial | imported | — |
| 130 | Handmade nail (barrel or treasure chest) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E17 |
| 131 | Handwrought iron hinge (small, chest) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | imported | S07E20 |
| 132 | Head Stone (human face/sword) | Carved Stones | Other | Modern | local | S01E01 |
| 133 | Heart-Shaped Stone (Nolan's Property) | Artifacts | Other Lots | Pre-Discovery | local | — |
| 134 | Heart-Shaped Stone (Smith's Cove) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | — |
| 135 | Hidden wooden box (Smith's Cove, Blankenship 1969-70) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | — |
| 136 | Hornfels Rock | Carved Stones | Island General | Ancient | local | — |
| 137 | Human bone fragments (2 individuals) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S05E05 |
| 138 | Inclined ramp (Smith's Cove, Blankenship 1969-70) | Structures | Smith's Cove | Medieval | local | — |
| 139 | Inscribed stone (90-foot stone) | Carved Stones | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S02E02 |
| 140 | Iron and lead strap (chest/box) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11E12 |
| 141 | Iron barrier {esc(x)} | Structures | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S02E09 |
| 142 | Iron cargo hook (Lot 11 well) | Tools | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S10E17 |
| 143 | Iron box or chest strap | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S09E08 |
| 144 | Iron chopping knife | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S13E14 |
| 145 | Iron Fire Grate Fragment | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E21 |
| 146 | Iron hinge (massive) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S06E16 |
| 147 | Iron Hook (Lot 5 Well) | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | local | S13E20 |
| 148 | Iron projectile (Lot 26, possible Roman pilum) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Shoreline | Ancient | imported | S06E03 |
| 149 | Iron scissors handles (Lot 5) | Tools | Island General | Colonial | imported | S13E04 |
| 150 | Iron ship's timber brace (burnt) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S07E14 |
| 151 | Iron Spike Boulder (Lot 2) | Artifacts | Other | unknown | local | S06E01 |
| 152 | Iron Staple (Quadrilateral) | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S10 |
| 153 | Iron swages (2 blacksmith tools) | Tools | Island General | Medieval | imported | — |
| 154 | Jewelled brooch (rhodolite garnet) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | — |
| 155 | Keg bottom (wooden) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | local | S07E19 |
| 156 | King George II coins, 18th century (multiple, island general) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S04E08 |
| 157 | King George II copper coin, 1771 (island general) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S02E03 |
| 158 | Kingdom Stone (Malkuth) | Carved Stones | Island General | Pre-Discovery | local | S01E04 |
| 159 | L-shaped wooden structure | Structures | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | S06E11 |
| 160 | Large boulder (TEFERET location) | Structures | The Swamp | Modern | local | S11E20 |
| 161 | Large copper coin, 1730s-1740s (Lot 25, Samuel Ball foundation) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S08E17 |
| 162 | Large-diameter pipe stem (Shaft 6) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S12E18 |
| 163 | Large log with Roman numerals (65 ft) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | S06E08 |
| 164 | Lead artifact (scalloped, Sardinian lead) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S10 |
| 165 | Lead Bag Seal - London, I. Lloyd Army Packers {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11E05 |
| 166 | Lead Bag Seal - Norwich Cloth | Artifacts | Other | Colonial | imported | S08E25 |
| 167 | Lead Bag Seal - Leeds, with Golden Fleece | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S13E10 |
| 168 | Lead coin weight (Lot 5 round feature) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | S12E04 |
| 169 | Lead cross {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Medieval | imported | S05E10 |
| 170 | Lead Decorative Piece | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S06E18 |
| 171 | Lead ingot (musket ball making) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S04E08 |
| 172 | Lead spoon handle | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S05E11 |
| 173 | Lead tag (Mediterranean origin) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S07E10 |
| 174 | Leaf/Fern Brooch | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | S07E04 |
| 175 | Leather book binding fragments | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S05E05 |
| 176 | Leather boot heel | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S08E12 |
| 177 | Leather Boot Sole | Artifacts | The Swamp | Pre-Discovery | imported | S12 |
| 178 | Leather Shoe Fragments | Artifacts | The Swamp | Medieval | imported | S13E15 |
| 179 | Lifting chain (wharf cargo) | Tools | The Swamp | Pre-Discovery | imported | S11E10 |
| 180 | Crude lime mortar fragments (Becker Hole B33) | Materials | Money Pit | Colonial | local | — |
| 181 | Lot 5 Standing Stone | Structures | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Modern | local | S13E04 |
| 182 | Lot 8 Giant Boulder | Structures | Island General | Pre-Discovery | local | S13E10 |
| 183 | Man-made stone tunnel {esc(x)} | Structures | Island General | Modern | local | S07E18 |
| 184 | Marlinespikes (pair) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S07E20 |
| 185 | Masonic 'G' stone {esc(x)} | Carved Stones | Smith's Cove | Pre-Discovery | local | S01E02 |
| 186 | Masonic Stone of Port Royal (1606) {esc(x)} | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Colonial | local | — |
| 187 | McGinnis Gold Cross {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S04E15 |
| 188 | Metal bits with fleur-de-lis design | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S06E05 |
| 189 | Metal fragment with gold traces | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | imported | S09E02 |
| 190 | Metal in pieces | Materials | Money Pit | Searcher Era | imported | S02E02 |
| 191 | Metal object from 171-foot void | Artifacts | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | imported | S03E12 |
| 192 | Metal pieces (200 ft depth) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | — |
| 193 | Metal pipe fragment (Smith's Cove, Blankenship 1969-70) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | — |
| 194 | Mi'kmaq pottery | Artifacts | The Swamp | Ancient | imported | S09E03 |
| 195 | Military-style Cuff Button {esc(x)} | Buttons | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E21 |
| 196 | Miner's oil lamp (whale oil) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S03E04 |
| 197 | Musket Ball (Lead Shot) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | imported | S11E20 |
| 198 | Musket Flintlock Mechanism {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | — |
| 199 | Nail from U-shaped structure timber (Smith's Cove, Blankenship 1969-70) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | — |
| 200 | New Ross Herm Stone | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Colonial | local | S04E01 |
| 201 | New Ross Well Symbol | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Pre-Discovery | local | S04E02 |
| 202 | Nolan's Cross (5 boulders) {esc(x)}{esc(x)} | Structures | Island General | Medieval | local | S01E01 |
| 203 | Oak buds in puddled clay (Becker Hole B11) | Samples | Money Pit | Colonial | local | — |
| 204 | Oak leaf and acorn (Restall collection) | Materials | Smith's Cove | Pre-Discovery | local | S07E21 |
| 205 | Oak log platforms (multiple) | Structures | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S01E01 |
| 206 | Oak peg (Smith's Cove U-shaped structure, GX-1692) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Medieval | local | — |
| 207 | Oak stumps (Mercy Point) | Materials | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S01E04 |
| 208 | Ornate Faceted Glass Jewel | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | imported | S12E20 |
| 209 | Ornate Floral Button | Buttons | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | imported | S12E22 |
| 210 | Ornate metal ring (flowered) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Pre-Discovery | imported | S07E19 |
| 211 | Overton Stone {esc(x)} | Carved Stones | Off-Island | Colonial | local | S03E03 |
| 212 | Ox shoes (multiple) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Pre-Discovery | imported | S08E03 |
| 213 | Parchment fragment | Artifacts | Money Pit | Searcher Era | imported | S05E06 |
| 214 | Parchment scrap (H8) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Medieval | imported | S05E05 |
| 215 | Paved Area / Stone Wharf | Structures | The Swamp | Medieval | local | S07E13 |
| 216 | Paving stone ramp/incline | Structures | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S10E19 |
| 217 | Peat deposits (Beach Pits 2 & 8) | Samples | South Shore | Ancient | local | — |
| 218 | Pewter Spoon Bowl | Artifacts | Shoreline | Colonial | imported | S08E02 |
| 219 | Pick Axe (Eye of the Swamp) | Artifacts | Other | Colonial | imported | S07E13 |
| 220 | Pick Axe | Tools | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S08E02 |
| 221 | Piece of chain + bone | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | local | S06E17 |
| 222 | Piece of wood containing traces of gold | Materials | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S10E15 |
| 223 | Pigmented Parchment Fragments | Artifacts | Money Pit | Medieval | imported | S06E13 |
| 224 | Pine Tar Kiln | Structures | Lot 15 | Colonial | local | S08E01 |
| 225 | Pink glass bead (17th century) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E20 |
| 226 | Pipe stem | Artifacts | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S06E18 |
| 227 | Plumb Bob | Tools | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S08E09 |
| 228 | Porcelain fragments | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | — |
| 229 | Portuguese Tornes, 1369-1371 (Pitblado coin) {esc(x)} | Coins | Money Pit | Medieval | imported | S13E01 |
| 230 | Possible box drain entrance {esc(x)} | Structures | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | S06E10 |
| 231 | Possible silver coin, post-1730s (Smith's Cove slipway) | Coins | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S06E17 |
| 232 | Pottery (18th century) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S10 |
| 233 | Pottery fragments (Smith's Cove ramp, Blankenship 1969-70) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | — |
| 234 | Pottery shard with raised leaf design | Artifacts | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | local | S05E10 |
| 235 | Pottery shards (mercury traces, Hedden find) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S05E12 |
| 236 | Pottery pieces (Lot 12 dump site) | Artifacts | Island General | Modern | imported | S05E12 |
| 237 | Pottery shards (Staffordshire pearlware) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S05E05 |
| 238 | Purple-stained wood fragment | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | local | S05E12 |
| 239 | Putty layer | Materials | Money Pit | Pre-Discovery | local | — |
| 240 | Quadrilateral boulder formation {esc(x)} | Structures | Other | Medieval | local | S10E18 |
| 241 | Queen Victoria copper halfpenny, c. 1840s (island general) | Coins | Island General | Searcher Era | imported | S07E04 |
| 242 | Ramrod Guide {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | local | S11E03 |
| 243 | Ramrod (musket rifle) {esc(x)} | Tools | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S12E21 |
| 244 | Rectangular structure (Lot 30) | Structures | Island General | Colonial | local | S10E04 |
| 245 | Red dye emerging at Smith's Cove | Samples | Money Pit | Modern | local | S06 |
| 246 | REDDEM Stone | Carved Stones | Other | Pre-Discovery | local | S03E06 |
| 247 | Wharf-Pin Ringbolt (Eastern Uplands) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S08E06 |
| 248 | Ring Bolt (Smith's Cove, Historical Account) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | unknown | imported | — |
| 249 | Ring Bolt (South Shore Cove, Blankenship) | Artifacts | South Shore | unknown | imported | — |
| 250 | Ring Bolt Rock (Lot 13) | Artifacts | The Swamp | unknown | local | S08E18 |
| 251 | Rock stake (ship anchor) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | local | S09E10 |
| 252 | Rock Wall (Lot26) {esc(x)} | Structures | Other | Colonial | local | S10E16 |
| 253 | Roman coin, 100-300 AD (Lot 5) {esc(x)} | Coins | Island General | Ancient | imported | S11E01 |
| 254 | Roman coin, pre-100 AD (Lot 5) {esc(x)} | Coins | Island General | Ancient | imported | S11E01 |
| 255 | Roman coin (Claudius II), 268-270 AD (Lot 5) {esc(x)} | Coins | Island General | Ancient | imported | S13E03 |
| 256 | Roman coin, 200-300 AD (Lot 5) {esc(x)} | Coins | Island General | Ancient | imported | S12E02 |
| 257 | Rose Head Spike (Karma-1) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S13E18 |
| 258 | Ruler/set square | Tools | Smith's Cove | Pre-Discovery | local | — |
| 259 | Rusty hook | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E10 |
| 260 | Sand Road (Western Swamp) | Structures | The Swamp | Medieval | local | S13E20 |
| 261 | Shear handle (Lot 5 shoreline) | Tools | Shoreline | Colonial | local | S11E04 |
| 262 | Ship spikes (numerous) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S05E05 |
| 263 | Ship's wooden pin | Artifacts | The Swamp | Pre-Discovery | local | S09E09 |
| 264 | Shotgun shell (Lot 8) | Artifacts | Lot 8 | Modern | imported | S13E11 |
| 265 | Silver button | Buttons | Other | Colonial | imported | — |
| 266 | Silver Spanish ring {esc(x)} | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S07E19 |
| 267 | Silver tassel piece (90% silver) | Artifacts | Island General | Pre-Discovery | imported | S11E19 |
| 268 | Silver traces ('dump-truck load') | Samples | Money Pit | Modern | local | S08 |
| 269 | Skeleton key | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S05E12 |
| 270 | Slag-like metal piece (Bowmaster dewatering hole) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | — |
| 271 | Slipway (wooden) | Structures | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | S06E11 |
| 272 | Small horseshoe (mule/pony) | Artifacts | Island General | Modern | imported | S05E08 |
| 273 | Spanish 11 maravedis, 1598 (Smith's Cove) {esc(x)} | Coins | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S05E02 |
| 274 | Spanish 8 maravedis copper, 1652 (swamp) {esc(x)} | Coins | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S01E05 |
| 275 | Spike (1700s wrought iron) | Artifacts | Smith's Cove | Colonial | imported | S06E08 |
| 276 | Spike coated in limestone/concrete {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S05E10 |
| 277 | Spruce platform | Structures | Money Pit | Colonial | local | — |
| 278 | Square nails | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S10 |
| 279 | Square-shaped hatch | Structures | Island General | Modern | local | S04E01 |
| 280 | Square Swamp Vault | Structures | Eye Of The Swamp | Colonial | local | S12E09 |
| 281 | Staffordshire slipware pottery | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S05E09 |
| 282 | Stained Wood Fragment | Artifacts | Money Pit | Searcher Era | local | S13E25 |
| 283 | Starburst button (lead-tin) | Buttons | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11E22 |
| 284 | Sticks/organic matter (Eye of the Swamp) | Materials | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S07E03 |
| 285 | Stone Cairns | Structures | Island General | Medieval | local | S11E16 |
| 286 | Stone and cement foundation (Smith's Cove) | Structures | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | — |
| 287 | Round stone feature (Lot 5) | Structures | Island General | Colonial | local | S10 |
| 288 | Stone cradle (Lot 8, under the giant boulder) | Structures | Lot 8 | Medieval | local | S13E17 |
| 289 | Stone Road | Structures | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S13E04 |
| 290 | Stone Shot (Money Pit) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Colonial | local | S08E14 |
| 291 | Stone Shot (Peacock 1) | Artifacts | Money Pit | Medieval | local | S13E21 |
| 292 | Stone Shot (Lot 16) | Artifacts | Other Lots | Colonial | local | S09E09 |
| 293 | Stone Triangle | Structures | Shoreline | Searcher Era | local | S03E08 |
| 294 | Stone well (Lot 11) | Structures | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S10E17 |
| 295 | Stone Well (Lot 5) | Structures | Other | Colonial | local | S13E20 |
| 296 | Stone well (never freezes) | Structures | Other Lots | Medieval | local | S13E24 |
| 297 | Submerged coin, undated, possibly Chinese (shoreline) | Coins | Shoreline | Modern | imported | S11E01 |
| 298 | Swivel Gun Metal {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Lot 4 Hole Under The Hatch | Colonial | imported | S09E07 |
| 299 | TD pipe stem (Thomas Dormer) | Artifacts | Lot 5 Stone Feature | Colonial | local | S12E07 |
| 300 | Textile fragment, red-dyed (Lot 8) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Lot 8 | Colonial | imported | S13E13 |
| 301 | Toe tap (leather and copper) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S10E16 |
| 302 | Tory Martin Stone | Carved Stones | Money Pit | Ancient | local | S06E10 |
| 303 | Trapezoid-Shaped Wood Piece | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | — |
| 304 | Treasure chest hinge | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S07E20 |
| 305 | Twisted metal, possible tool fragment (MP-1, 195 ft) | Artifacts | Money Pit | — | imported | S13E25 |
| 306 | Two copper coins, undated (Lot 5 round feature) | Coins | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E03 |
| 307 | U-shaped wooden structure | Structures | Smith's Cove | Colonial | local | S05E16 |
| 308 | Unknown tunnel (east-west) {esc(x)} | Structures | Money Pit | Modern | local | S10E01 |
| 309 | Unusual coin or token with webbing design, undated (Money Pit) | Coins | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S06E12 |
| 310 | Venetian glass beads (multiple) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S11E10 |
| 311 | Wharf pin nail (1700s) | Artifacts | Island General | Colonial | imported | S12E19 |
| 312 | Wharf pin (large iron) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | S12E16 |
| 313 | William III sixpence, 1697-1701 (Lot 18) | Coins | Money Pit | Colonial | imported | S13E25 |
| 314 | Wood, clay, charcoal (various boreholes) | Materials | Money Pit | Colonial | local | — |
| 315 | Wood from 2A shaft | Artifacts | Money Pit | Modern | local | S12E01 |
| 316 | Wood slat and wooden stake (Triton Alliance, 1981) | Materials | Other Lots | Ancient | local | — |
| 317 | Wooden cargo barrel fragments {esc(x)} | Artifacts | The Swamp | Medieval | local | S09E02 |
| 318 | Wooden keg barrel pieces | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S13E14 |
| 319 | Wooden Ship's Plank | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S04E03 |
| 320 | Wooden ship's railing {esc(x)} | Artifacts | The Swamp | Medieval | local | S08E21 |
| 321 | Wooden Stakes | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S07E11 |
| 322 | Wooden T-square / masonic tool {esc(x)} | Tools | The Swamp | Colonial | local | S08E22 |
| 323 | Wound glass bead (forest glass, Normandy) {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Island General | Medieval | imported | S12E21 |
| 324 | Wrought iron scissors | Tools | Smith's Cove | Pre-Discovery | imported | S11E04 |
| 325 | Wrought iron spike (swamp) | Artifacts | The Swamp | Colonial | imported | — |
| 326 | Yarmouth Runic Stone {esc(x)} | Artifacts | Off-Island | Medieval | local | S06E03 |